by R. Daniel Mann Question: Are there any things to be careful about when cooking for Shabbat on Yom Tov that falls out on Friday, with the help of an eiruv tavshilin (=et)? Answer: The laws of cooking on Yom Tov are the same when done for Shabbat (with an et) as when done for Yom Tov eating, concerning what ...
Read More »
by R. Daniel Mann Question: We want to plant a fruit tree in our yard, but if we can work it out, we will expand our house and will need to uproot the tree. Is it alright to plant it in these circumstances? Answer: The Torah forbids cutting down fruit trees (Devarim 20:19). This is the strictest application of the ...
Read More »
by R. Daniel Mann Question: This Shabbat (Vayakhel/Pekudei), the gabbai called up a levi for shvii, and as ba’al korei, I knew he was going to make a hosafa and give acharon/chazak to someone else. I quickly told him the levi cannot come up, but that they should switch the intended olim, having the levi wait for acharon. After laining, ...
Read More »
by R. Daniel Mann Question: During laining on Shabbat, I noticed dirt of some sort that distorted a letter of the sefer Torah. I pushed it with my tallit, and it readily came off. Did I violate Shabbat? Answer: The classic case of the melacha of mochek (erasing) is to erase letters or a form in order to afterward write ...
Read More »
by R. Daniel Mann Question: What are the rules about correcting a ba’al korei? Answer: The Tur (Orach Chayim 142) seems to present a polar machloket on the matter. The Rambam (Tefilla 12:6) rules that if one made a mistake even on a single “dikduk” of a letter, we make him go back. Hamanhig (p. 160) prefers not correcting to ...
Read More »
by R. Daniel Mann Question: The fledgling community of which I am rabbi does not have access for Kabbalat Shabbat to the place we daven on Shabbat morning, so we have a rotation of houses for it. Should we say Me’ein Sheva (the beracha with “Magen avot…” in its midst) at Maariv? Answer: Me’ein Sheva (=MS) is like a shortened ...
Read More »
by R. Daniel Mann Question: I never do tevillat keilim after Pesach on keilim I sell. Can that be justified? Answer: Your excellent question has been bothering Acharonim for centuries. If one follows the apparent consequences of mechirat chametz, the relevant keilim should require tevilla because when a Jew sells a kli to a non-Jew and buys it back, it ...
Read More »
by R. Daniel Mann Question: We (Israelis) will be spending Pesach at my parents’ home in chutz la’aretz. They keep the basics of the chag, especially when we are there, but do not observe Yom Tov Sheini (=YTS). May we benefit from forbidden melacha (ed. note – e.g., turning on a flame or electricity for cooking; turning on lights) they ...
Read More »
by R. Daniel Mann Question: What are the rules of when one does and does not do nefilat apayim (putting one’s head down and partially covering it) during Tachanun? Answer: The sources and depth of discussion regarding this question are underwhelming, but the background is fascinating. Although no mishna mandates doing nefilat apayim in davening, several gemarot (including Megilla 22b ...
Read More »
by R. Daniel Mann Question: I give a shiur to a few people before Shacharit and aim to finish when davening begins, with Rabbi Yishmael/Kaddish D’Rabbanan. Sometimes we are not quite finished then, in which case, we try to answer Kaddish’s main recitations, although we sometimes get caught up and fail to respond. Someone complained that continuing to learn during ...
Read More »