HalachahLatest EssaysMagazine
Smelling A Cinnamon Bun
by R. Ephraim Glatt, Esq.
Question: Should one recite a b’rachah on a cinnamon bun if he picks it up solely to smell?
Short Answer: According to many poskim, no smelling b’rachah is recited, and, in fact, one should refrain from picking up a cinnamon bun just to smell.
Explanation:
I. Two Opinions of the Beis Yosef & Rama
The Beis Yosef (O”C 297:5) cites the Kol Bo, Abudraham, and Orchos Chaim who hold that one may use hot bread for besamim on Motzei Shabbos if he has no other besamim. The precise b’rachah is debated within these poskim — whether you recite (i) borei minei besamim or (ii) shenassan rei’ach tov b’pas.
Regardless, the Beis Yosef himself disagrees. He doubts that any b’rachah is recited on hot bread, as there is no mention whatsoever of such a b’rachah in the Mishnah and Gemara.
The Rama (O”C 216:14) cites the two opinions. Some hold that one recites “shenassan rei’ach tov b’pas” on smelling hot bread, while others hold that no b’rachah is recited.
II. The Explanation
Mishnah B’rurah (O”C 216:54) explains the first opinion, that one recites a smelling b’rachah on hot bread, by simply referring to the general halachah (see Article #1) that one recites a smelling b’rachah if he picks up a fruit to smell. Indeed, as discussed earlier (Article #1), the Mishnah B’rurah holds that even if the fruit is picked up with intent to eat and smell, the smelling b’rachah is recited. The Vilna Gaon (discussed ibid), according to the Damesek Eliezer, disagrees, that fruit only gets a smelling b’rachah where the fruit is solely picked up to smell. The Chazon Ish took it a step further, that fruit never gets a smelling b’rachah unless it is actually designated for smelling (and not for eating).
Presumably, the second opinion, that no smelling b’rachah is recited on hot bread, holds like the Vilna Gaon, that bread does not receive a smelling b’rachah because it generally is only eaten and not picked up to smell. Nevertheless, the Mishnah B’rurah (O”C 216:55) gives a different explanation for this second opinion, that hot bread does not have a strong enough smell to require a smelling b’rachah. Accordingly, the Shaar Hatzion (57) holds that even if you pick up the hot bread solely to smell, no smelling b’rachah is recited. He does note, however, that the Vilna Gaon gives our original explanation, that the bread is picked up to eat; ergo, if picked up for smell as well, a smelling b’rachah would be recited.
The Shaar Hatzion (57) concludes that “safeik b’rachos l’hakel,” that even if one picks up the hot bread to smell, no smelling b’rachah should be recited, as we are concerned for the second opinion and the explanation that the smell is not strong enough for a b’rachah.
III. The Aruch Hashulchan
Aruch Hashulchan (O”C 216:14) likewise cites both opinions of the Rama. However, he adds that he does understand the first opinion, as hot bread by itself has no smell. He suggests that it means bread with butter or spices. Regardless, the Aruch Hashulchan holds that no smelling b’rachah should be recited on bread or any other cooked dishes that have a nice smell, as the person does not intend to smell them.
The implication of the Aruch Hashulchan though is that if a person picks up a food or dish to smell, and it has a strong smell, a smelling b’rachah should be recited. Nevertheless, he has “never heard” of anyone making such a b’rachah.
Indeed, the sefer V’Zos Hab’rachah (p.178) adopts the Mishnah B’rurah and Aruch Hashulchan, ruling simply that one should not recite a smelling b’rachah on hot bread or hot dishes. This is also the ruling of Shaarei HaB’rachah (19:32, n.66).
IV. Cinnamon
But what about if the bread or dish has cinnamon, such as a cinnamon bun? Does one make a b’rachah on the cinnamon if he picks up the bun to smell?
In general, there is a dispute about the b’rachah on smelling cinnamon. Shulchan Aruch (O”C 216:2) holds that “kanila,” which according to Mishnah B’rurah (15) is cinnamon, gets a smelling b’rachah of “hanosein rei’ach tov b’peiros.” Others, including the Elya Rabbah (ibid), hold that “borei minei besamim” is more appropriate.
Regardless, most poskim, as discussed in Piskei Teshuvos (O”C 216), hold that we never recite a smelling b’rachah on bread or dessert even if it has a good smell from a spice, based on the Mishnah B’rurah, Aruch Hashulchan, and Chazon Ish (above). In fact, they advise that in order to avoid any problem, one should never intentionally smell a cake or bread.
Indeed, the sefer Borei Minei Besamim (R’ Avraham Adas, p.42) writes that according to Shulchan Aruch and Mishnah B’rurah, a b’rachah would be recited, as you are picking up the cake to smell the bun and the smell is strong enough for a b’rachah. Nevertheless, because the Vilna Gaon and Chazon Ish disagree, no b’rachah should be recited and one should refrain from smelling them.
