Larger PictureLatest EssaysMagazineRav GidonWeekly Torah Reading Resources

Making Good People

by R. Gidon Rothstein

Parshat Noach

Hacking Away at Noach’s Excellence

Our parsha leads with Noach and his virtues, he is a tzaddik, tamim be-dorotav, and et Ha-Elokim hithalech Noach, something along the lines of Noach walked with God. Laudatory as it might seem, later commentators saw subtle minimizations of what was, nonetheless, a level of greatness.

Onkelos focused “walking with God” on fear, seemed to locate his excellence in having achieved such fear. Not the love Avraham cultivated, as Rashi famously contrasted, but good enough to stand out from his generation.

Ramban, too, reduced the merit in the adjectives. Being a tzaddik, in his view, meant Noach only refrained from what a court would condemn, did not steal or engage in any financial wrongs. As opposed to Avraham, who also acted in accordance with mishpat, yet added tzedakah, positive acts of good.

Staying away from bad gets us further than we might assume, however. Ramban thinks “walked with God” includes rejecting the corruptions of the generation, forcible theft, divination, idolatry. Enough, Ramban says, to be considered a tzaddik, even to be a prophet, with whom God “spoke” more than once. A lesson he recommends we learn, rejecting temptations to corruption and false prophets counts as walking with God.

Yielding to bad, for the other hand, caused the Flood, Onkelos stresses. While Rashi read the Torah to mean animals, too, had descended into sexual perversion, Onkelos highlighted what people had done as the cause, their misplaced sexuality and financial wrongs. When, after the Flood, Hashem decides never to bring another one because of people, Onkelos again focuses on its having been human misdeeds that led to it.

The Flood Approaches

When the Flood started, Rashi noticed the Torah’s describing the early water as rain, rather than flood, explained it still could have been rain, even rain of blessing, had the people realized what was coming and repented.

It helped Chatam Sofer explain a puzzling idea of Ramban’s. Ramban wondered why Noach was told to take the kosher animals onto the Ark, where the nonkosher ones presented themselves. He suggested it would have been unfair to require animals to show up for their own killing.

Chatam Sofer objects that their other option was dying in the flood, so what would have been bad about having them come to the ark, where they would live until someone wanted to eat them? Our Rashi explains—until the last moment, there was the possibility of repentance, so staying away from the Ark would not have meant certain death.

How the Flood Hit

Two comments paid attention to the Flood’s impact. For the Land of Israel, Ramban was sure no rain fell there, nor did water bubble up from the earth. Water did flow there from the rest of the world, but with less force, leaving trees standing and undamaged.

Turning to the spiritual, Meshech Chochmah was sure the Flood changed the Ark’s inhabitants, the reason it took a full year. God could have wiped out the world much faster, but the people and animals on the Ark had to be retrained, needed to know to handle finances and sexuality better, and that took time. When they came off the Ark, they were renewed, re-educated, and ready to rebuild God’s world.

Noach Leaves the Ark

To know when to leave, Netziv was sure Noach sent his own personal birds, not those brought onto the Ark to save the species. The raven came back empty-handed, and was worried he would be rejected as a failure. Noach’s taking him back was a lesson in compassion for those whose efforts fail through no fault of their own.

When he finally leaves the Ark, Noach builds an altar, a chance for Onkelos to show where he does and doesn’t worry about speaking of God in excessively human terms. The altar was before God, rather than to God, and God’s smelling the pleasant smell was accepting Noach’s offering with goodwill.

David Tzvi Hoffmann gave Noach credit for having offered many more species of animals and birds than later became the Torah’s model, a greater representation of humanity. Noach also offered olot, burnt animal offerings, an advance over previous sacrifices, which were menachot, flour offerings. An olah not only offers all the animal, for R. Hoffmann, it expresses the human desire to go up, to rise towards Hashem.

Hashem Reshapes the World

The sacrifice leads Hashem to declare He will never again curse the earth or punish all life because of humans, whose inclinations are evil from childhood. Or HaChayim saw an example of an idea he knew from elsewhere, those trained in a certain way are not fully blamed for acting on their training. People’s evil inclination comes with birth, has time to get rooted and set our direction before we begin studying Torah, learning the right way to act, and so on.

So how could we be fully culpable?

At the same time, Hashem does ask/require humans to help put the world on a better path. Hashem has blessings and commands for Noach and his descendants, among them the responsibility to react to murder, find and punish the murderer. Sforno reads the Torah’s phrasing to refer to the idea of a go’el ha-dam, a relative of a murder victim, who must find the murderer and ensure the murderer is punished appropriately.

It is not left to humans alone, though, Hashem tells Noach He will demand an accounting for human blood. Malbim sees a contrast to animals, who are available for killing, where even suicide is prohibited to humans, God will settle the score with even a suicide’s immortal soul, for the wrong s/he did.

Judges and Judging

The same sentence, for Malbim, teaches us the lesser standard of evidence and court procedure in non-Jewish courts. Like Hashem, courts will insist on a reckoning for human blood, even without warning, even with one witness, even with one judge. Onkelos contrasted it the opposite way, stressed the need for a court, some court procedure, with witnesses or evidence, the judges deliberating to verdict. Not vigilantes taking the law into their own hands.

The right to judge, Meshech Chochmah thought, stems from humanity’s having been created be-tzelem Elokim, with a divine spark. Later in the parsha, when God “descends” to see the Tower of Bavel, Rashi takes this to be an action we must emulate, to investigate before reaching a verdict, even for cases where we are confident of the outcome.

He also sees the limits in our ability to judge, driven home to him by the Torah’s following up the verse on responding to murder with one about procreation. We have no right to judge whether the world needs more children, or is a place we want to put children. That, we have no right to judge, our job is to have the children, because God told us to. Whatever results there we cannot handle, we leave to God.

Moving On From the Flood

The next major incident in the parsha is Migdal Bavel, the Tower of Bavel. Just prior to that, Ramban spotted the first king for humanity, a development he linked to war. People’s worry about military success was what led them to cede their sovereignty to one leader.

For the Tower, people famously lost their common language, and scattered over the earth. R. Samson Raphael Hirsch thought it was already happening, a natural outcome of population growth. Rises in numbers lead people to migrate to new places, and the new situations lead to changes and developments of language. God’s decision at the Tower, in his view, only accelerated an existing process.

Ibn Ezra took an almost opposite view, language prior to the Tower was kept stagnant and easy, for everyone to understand without effort. He seems to think the generation of the Tower lost sight of the growth to be earned through overcoming difficulties, and wanted to keep it that way, keep language and life dumb and simple. Hashem messed up the languages to force us into the elevating struggle for comprehension.

The Not Obvious Errors of the Tower

Ibn Ezra also gives the impression the reasons given to build the Tower were convincing enough for Noach, Shem, Peleg, and perhaps Avraham (depending on when we time its building) to have participated. He doesn’t say more, but if these greats could all be part of it, the flaws in its conception were apparently not obvious.

Rashi and R. Ya’akov Tzvi Mecklenburg differ on how the people explained the value of the Tower. Rashi thought they decided floods like the one Noach survived were natural, happened on a cycle, and this Tower could stave off the one slated to come 1656 years later. An example of humanity’s overconfidence in their ability to understand the workings of the world, as well as their ability to bend the world to their will.

Ha-Ketav Ve-Ha-Kabbalah instead saw an almost opposite role to the Tower, understood it to be a way to elicit the help of a supernatural being (not God), who could overrule whatever natural disasters loomed.

Either way, the Tower brings God’s response, which for Onkelos seems to include Hashem preventing them from building what they had intended (instead of, for example, destroying the Tower and scattering them).

With two central incidents, the Flood and the Tower of Bavel, our commentators showed us instances of how we spot good and what it is. Noach, less good than Avraham, perhaps focused on not doing wrong, yet was good enough to be the sole survivor of the Flood, understood enough to launch a new society, where humans had the right and responsibility to judge murder but not procreation, where the society they built tripped up over the Tower, but moved on to continue the world.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button