Audio Roundup Special: Monei Mitzvot

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

by Joel Rich

ספרי מניין המצוות של הראשונים: מגמות חינוכיות |  | הרב אליקים קרומביין
שיעור 1
While the concept of 613 mitzvot is Talmudic, actual lists of mitzvot were a later development.  Post-geonic lists were more than just a listing.  The Smak was writing for the general public and included rabbinic mitzvot.  His focus was on how to do the mitzvot because he felt people lacked knowledge.
שיעור 2
        The Smak’s widespread impact was by design, he gave the people the knowledge he felt they were missing.  Rabbeinu Yonah put the mitzvot in his mussar works because he felt the people were missing consciousness, not knowledge.
שיעור 3
        Examples of R’Yonah’s consciousness raising through mitzvot explanations (e.g. bal taschit – don’t buy things you really don’t need.)  We need to be conscious of our great responsibility.
שיעור 4
        The Rambam wrote his sefer hamitzvot in order to ensure that he included all he needed in the mishna torah.  He felt there were errors in the prior mitzvot listing attempts and thus he had to set out rules so everyone would understand the correct information. (and recognize prior errors)
שיעור 5
        The Rambam viewed the list of mitzvot as the essential basis (ekronot) for halacha (e.g. hilchot mechira, tumat meit) upon which he built the full structure.  Then intro to the sefer hachinuch (who generally followed the Rambam)
שיעור 6
        The sefer hachinuch followed the Rambam and wanted his students to continue the focus on “real” learning.  Maybe the author wanted to remain anonymous so it wouldn’t seem his disagreement was a personal fight with R’Yonah.


About Joel Rich

Joel Rich is a frequent wannabee cyberspace lecturer on various Torah topics. A Yerushalmi formerly temporarily living in West Orange, NJ, his former employer and the Social Security administration support his Torah listening habits. He is a recovering consulting actuary.

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to our Weekly Newsletter

The latest weekly digest is also available by clicking here.

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter