From The Jewish Thought FilesLatest EssaysMagazineMusings

Are Women Better?

by R. Gil Student

Four years ago, we published two articles about women’s spiritual status in Judaism — one in which I quote a number of nineteenth and twentieth century thinkers who argue that women are spiritually equal to, or greater than, men and another by Rav Moshe Zuriel who explains the Maharal’s view that women are greater in some aspects and men are greater in other aspects. I recently came across relevant discussions of this issue in sixteenth century texts.

I. Yefeh To’ar

In discussing the sequence of Creation, the midrash (Bereishis Rabbah 19:4) says that order counts:

R. Yehudah bar Simon said: Everything that was created after its fellow, rules over its fellow… And Adam was created after all to rule over all.

Ostensibly, this would imply that women should rule over men, since female was created after male (Gen. 2:21). However, Rav Shmuel Yaffe Ashkenazi, in his Yefeh To’ar commentary, questions why the midrash does not say that people rule over land animals. He suggests that the midrash is only addressing the days of Creation. Things created on a later day rule over things created on an earlier day. However, that implication does not apply within the same day.

Therefore, people do not rule over animals. Similarly, the ten things created bein ha-shemashos, around sunset on Friday, do not rule over man. Based on this, the Yefeh To’ar would reject the suggestion that women are better than men because they were created later. Since they were created on the same day, the order lacks that implication.

II. Maharshdam

The Maharashdam — Rav Shmuel Di Modena — was a rabbi in Salonica in the mid-sixteenth century. After his death, his son collected his sermons and published them as Sefer Ben Shmuel. The book was only published once, in 1582, until its recent republication. In 2015, it was published in a new, corrected edition as part of a fourth volume in the new edition of the Maharshdam’s responsa.

The eighth sermon addresses this question at length. The Maharshdam points out that Shem Tov Ben Shem Tov asks why women were created last if they aren’t the highest level (Derashos, Bereishis, Derush Le-Chupah).

Maharshdam gives his own answer — if woman was created before man, it would seem like her task is to serve man like all the animals that were created before man and are intended to serve man. This is not the case — a woman exists for herself, not for her husband (שמציאותה בשביל עצמה). Rather both man and woman are created for themselves, to subjugate their physicality to their intellect. Since a woman is more physical by nature, if she overcomes this she reaches a higher level than man. “A woman, with all her flaws, can perfect herself like a man and more (אפשר לאשה עם כל פחיתותה להשלים עצמה כאיש ויותר).”

Maharshdam is not some proto-feminist, as you can see in his language. He believes that women are different from men. Women are associated with physicality. Remember that in his time women spent most of their time doing menial work in the home. Men worked, as well, but generally spent at least some time engaged in intellectual pursuits. However, both men and women can overcome their physicality. Since women are more associated with physicality, if they overcome it they reach higher levels than men.

It is unclear what these higher levels mean. It could mean merely that women receive more reward for overcoming their greater challenge, as Maharshdam says in one place in this passage. Or it could mean that women reach higher spiritual levels because they succeeded in a greater challenge. While not directly equivalent to twentieth century approaches, Maharshdam’s maintains important parallels that serve as an intellectual support to the later thinkers.

As we have seen, the disagreement over this subject that we see today existed 500 years ago in Greece, when it was a great center of Torah.

Gil Student

Rabbi Gil Student is the Editor of TorahMusings.com, a leading website on Orthodox Jewish scholarly subjects, and Director of the Halacha Commission of the Rabbinical Alliance of America. He writes a popular column on issues of Jewish law and thought featured in newspapers and magazines, including the Orthodox Union’s Jewish Action magazine, The Jewish Link and The Jewish Vues. In the past, he has served as the President of the small Jewish publisher Yashar Books and as the Managing Editor of OU Press. Rabbi Student has served three terms on the Executive Committee of the Rabbinical Council of America.. He works as the Director of Jewish Media, Publications and Editorial Communications at the Orthodox Union. He has published five English books, the most recent titled Articles of Faith: Traditional Jewish Belief in the Internet Era, previously served as the Book Editor of Jewish Action magazine, and served as the American editor for Morasha Kehillat Yaakov: Essays in Honour of Chief Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button